Related links
Teams
Also see
- Minute-by-minute from Twickers
- Moody laments England errors
Following a demoralising defeat to Scotland, the embattled Springboks went from zero to hero in the space of a week after beating England 21-11 at Twickenham on Saturday.
South Africa dusted themselves off from a miserable afternoon at Murrayfield to silence their critics with a powerful performance that made up for last week's effort ten-fold.
It was an incredible return of serve from the world champions who may have had their Grand Slam dreams dashed, but at least restored some pride with one game left to play on tour against the Barbarians at the same venue next weekend.
Once again, the Boks' proved that they are a different kettle of fish with their backs up against the wall as England were left to find out the hard way - enduring a seventh consecutive defeat to the men in green and gold.
The visiting pack was immense, dominating the collisions and set-pieces - their line-out was simply outstanding - however the backline were less impressive, making too many handling errors and lacking penetration on attack.
But it didn't matter as England were a shadow of the team that smashed the Wallabies two weeks ago. Out-thought and out-fought. That was the bottom line for England in an encounter which was not so much a rugby match as an arm-wrestle.
Gone were the pretty patterns woven by England in recent weeks. Instead they found themselves scrapping for possession. Desperately shoring up their defence. Fighting for their lives against the toughest, meanest team in rugby. They came up short.
The sides were level at half-time but after losing the influential Tom Croft and Toby Flood shortly before the break, England conceded a soft penalty straight after and it was all South Africa thereafter as the hosts wilted under pressure.
Replacement Willem Alberts was sent over in the right-hand corner before debutant winger Lwazi Mvovo ghosted through a stationary England backline five minutes later to effectively seal matters.
An intercept try from full-back Ben Foden two minutes from the end represented scant consolation for Martin Johnson's men, who battled hard but ultimately failed to deal with the might of the Springboks pack.
Toby Flood got the ball rolling with a straight-forward penalty in the fifth minute after a scintillating 30m run from Tom Croft that took play into kicking range for his fly-half, who didn't disappoint. It was just reward for an all-out England counter-attack instigated by Nick Easter.
The physicality of the match nearly claimed its first victim in the form of Chris Ashton following a mistimed tackle on Bok skipper Victor Matfield that saw the England winger come off second best. Dazed, Ashton saw more than stars flying over his head as Morne Steyn leveled the scores with a well-struck penalty in the tenth minute.
The big hits kept coming in, and this time it was the impressive-looking Croft who felt the punishing effects of a brutal Test that would see the flanker forced off the pitch clutching his forearm. It was a cruel blow for England, but the hosts pressed on and took the lead once more thanks to another three points from Flood.
At this point it seemed whatever England did, South Africa could do better as the world champions clicked into a higher gear and nearly accelerated over the line only for Matfield to have the ball knocked from his grasp with the tryline begging.
The missed opportunities wouldn't end there for the Boks, however, after the two Steyns - Morne and Francois - watched in angst as their respective penalty efforts hit the posts and denied South Africa six points.
Flood, injured in the build-up to the Matfield effort, failed to make the interval and was replaced by Charlie Hodgson, while opposite number Steyn levelled matters four minutes before the end of the half after England spoiled a ruck on their own line.
Three minutes after the break and South Africa were ahead for the first time - veteran Mike Tindall spotted in an offside position.
England responded well though, driving towards the line through Dylan Hartley and Easter, and although they camped on the try-line for several minutes looking for an opening, Easter was hit by three defenders and the ball fell clear as the Springboks survived.
South Africa began to ring the changes with prop CJ Van Der Linde and flanker Alberts sent on - and both made an immediate impact.
The England scrum struggled as the Springboks wheeled one and then hooked a ball against the head. Morne Steyn kicked ahead and wing Mark Cueto conceded the line-out.
South Africa drove through phase after phase before moving the ball wide and number eight Pierre Spies' wonderful, delayed pass sent Alberts over in the corner. Morne Steyn was off-target with the conversion, but it had become a war of attrition and in such circumstances there was only likely to be one outcome.
Hodgson tried a cross-kick which Mvovo gathered and he then drew the penalty as Ashton and Shontayne Hape came off their feet and Morne Steyn teed up the attacking line-out.
Both Steyns dropped back into position for a drop goal but the Springboks instead worked the ball wide for Mvovo, who brushed past Ashton to score on 70 minutes.
England never really looked like creating an opening were before they gifted a late try after Foden picked off Van Der Linde's offload and sprinted 90 metres to score. Tindall tried the quick drop-goal conversion and hit the post, summing up their afternoon.
Man of the match: While Bismarck du Plessis was named the official man of the match, it could have gone to any of the Bok heavies. Which is why we're going for a collective effort! Special mention for England lock Courtney Lawes - he was everywhere!
Moment of the match: Tough to choose between new Bok recruits Willem Alberts and Lwazi Mvovo. But we'll go for Mvovo's touchdown, as the Bok speedster sealed the win with his first Test try.
Villain of the match: None spring to mind, but we have a funny feeling you'll prove us wrong - answers on a postcard please!
The scorers:
For England:
Try: Foden
Pens: Flood 2
For South Africa:
Tries: Alberts, Mvovo
Cons: M Steyn
Pens: M Steyn 3
England: 15 Ben Foden, 14 Chris Ashton, 13 Mike Tindall, 12 Shontayne Hape, 11 Mark Cueto, 10 Toby Flood, 9 Ben Youngs, 8 Nick Easter, 7 Lewis Moody (c), 6 Tom Croft, 5 Tom Palmer, 4 Courtney Lawes, 3 Dan Cole, 2 Dylan Hartley, 1 Andrew Sheridan.
Replacements: 16 Steve Thompson, 17 David Wilson, 18 Simon Shaw, 19 Hendre Fourie, 20 Danny Care, 21 Charlie Hodgson, 22 Matt Banahan.
South Africa: 15 Zane Kirchner, 14 Gio Aplon, 13 Frans Steyn, 12 Jean De Villiers, 11 Lwazi Mvovo, 10 Morne Steyn, 9 Ruan Pienaar, 8 Pierre Spies, 7 Juan Smith, 6 Deon Stegmann, 5 Victor Matfield (capt), 4 Bakkies Botha, 3 Jannie du Plessis, 2 Bismarck du Plessis, 1 Tendai Mtawarira.
Replacements: 16 Adriaan Strauss, 17 CJ Van der Linde, 18 Flip van der Merwe, 19 Willem Alberts, 20 Francois Hougaard, 21 Patrick Lambie, 22 Adi Jacobs.
Referee: George Clancy (Ireland)
Comments
Brett says...
@justice4all.aka"student of racial politics" I was born, lived and fought in "racial politics" which foremost made me into a realist !
I find it ironic that we are talking about colour quotas that you claim dont excist but in the same line you refer to the talentless PDV , still dont see it?
Or is it merely the fact that you dont watch SA domestic competition to know what players deserve to be in the Bok side on playing ability alone! ps refering to your last sentence seeing as you must be in your eighties I respect the fact that maybe you cannot see the big picture anymore
Posted 18:58 01st December 2010
justice_4_all says...
@brett..I was hoping that we were past all that colour-quota crap? Frankly I don't see it. I think that PDV is not a great picker of talent...and God knows he's weak or non existent on strategy and tactics and has a game plan that wouldn't win at dominos ....BUT I don't see this colour bias you talk of....and I have been a student of racial politics since your father was in short pants
Posted 22:24 29th November 2010
justice_4_all says...
.@Cass402 You are 100% right with your comment re "with humility both in victory and defeat." I console myself with the observation that the tossers who don't adhere to this seem to be evenly spread across all countries...IQs around the same as their shoe size?
Posted 22:01 29th November 2010
jehosophat says...
Some pretty unpleasant and one-eyed anti-English sentiment here.... We have a large and often daft media, for sure, but we don't take what they say as gospel! Personally I like to read reviews of England matches in the non-English media to get a different opinion - it is usually more balanced than some of the ranting below. All the 6N teams are consistently below trinations standards currently but I can't see England failing to contest the 6N - it will be the battle of the mediocre. I thought France were improving, and thought England would have a decent fillip if they beat SA, but both slumped poorly.
I would agree that both sides from Twickenham on Saturday have a lot of work to do. England are out of the dire straits of losing by 20-30+ points at home to the trinations sides - with that being our standard in recent years no wonder we feel a bit happier now - but have to compete more consistently and find more leaders on the pitch. Johnson - who had no coaching qualifications at all - made his one big step forward earlier this year when he finally picked on form and allowed in some young blood like Lawes, Ashton and Foden. He has more to do on that front.
SA played a good game on Saturday but are inconsistent and one dimensional even when playing well. They have the players, so it can be sorted out. Australia and France (until the weekend) seem on the right track and have their moments, Wales and Ireland are consistently good but seem to lack the depth to be great. NZ are a class apart. But a lot can happen between now and the RWC and luckily there are always surprises and shocks at a major tournament - otherwise we might as well hand NZ the cup now.
Posted 13:32 29th November 2010
smarty says...
The lesson that sides can learn from the Springboks win the weekend is that to beat the bokke you first need to match them up front. If you do that and outplay them in the backline (which is not too tricky) then you will win....but if you cant then 9/10 you will lose. At this stage only the AB's can do that. The Aussies will be cannon fodder at the RWC based on current form of their forwards. As excellent as their backline is I cannot see them being contenders until this is resolved.
Most importantly I do not beleive that the bokke must change their game plan to be one of "exciting" backline running etc. like the Kiwi's and Aussies do. I love the forward dominated play with the backs converting when we have position. I think that it is stupid to even contemplate trying to become something they aren't. If they execute that game plan well they can even beat the AB's. When it comes to the RWC all sides will tone down their risky backline moves as it takes just one interception and you are out (AB's note this point!)
For those that think backline play is the beginning and end of Union can I suggets rugby league!
Posted 12:08 29th November 2010
Cass402 says...
@thaighott.
What are you moaning about..Moody said the best team won! He was merely pointing out that Englands precision should have been better.If you want a whinge then Victor Matfield, talking directly after Moody mentioned that the weather was terrible when they lost to Scotland...if i was as paranoid or one eyed as you i would have read between the lines and assumed that the loss was down to the weather and not the Scots!!! I personally think that every captain of all the competing sides have acted as i would expect an international captain to behave...with humility both in victory and defeat. Its a shame some of the morons posting on here could'nt do the same.
Posted 06:48 29th November 2010
Clinton says...
I wouldn't read too much into the performance of either team on Saturday. England made very basic handling errors and the backline could not find any rythm at all. South Africa was as one-dimensional as ever. The forwards did well to gain the upperhand, but the backline was horrible, horrible! It must be said that Zane Kirchner is no international fullback by a long shot. Morne Steyn failed yet again to get the centres on the front foot. Forwards belong in the rucks and mauls. If Victor stayed out of the backline that would have been a try. A backline player would've been able to finish that move off much more effectively. And CJ van der Linde can thank his lucky stars that that stupid pass did not result in the winning try for England. It was four Boks on 3 English in that move - it should have been a straight-forward try under the posts for the Boks!!!! I cannot stress it enough that forwards must stop believing they can double-up as international quality backline players!! Stay out of there and let the like of Jean de Villiers and Frans Steyn deal with their own responsibilities. As for England, let's face it - South Africa didn't play well enough to beat them. England simply played badly enough to lose, and the same goes for the other way around. Both teams did badly enough to lose this game. The only reason why SA won is because they were able to overpower England upfront, where it all starts. Congrats to my team nevertheless. But I won't get too excited about next year just yet.
Posted 05:49 29th November 2010
sjambok says...
Compare teh backline play of Australia with the clueles backline play of SA this last weekend - light years difference!! Dick Muir must GO!
Posted 22:14 28th November 2010
couchspud says...
@Brett
you have my sympathy in regards to that situation, it is crap and there should be no place for it in sport.
PVD is still not your best optition but what do you do???
Posted 20:07 28th November 2010
undecided says...
One of the best reffing performances i've seen in a long time.
Posted 16:58 28th November 2010
safehands says...
....the only thing standing in the way of the Boks and the RWC is PdV.......hahahaha!! I haven't laughed as much as that for a long time...seems a lot of the Saffa fans are as delusional as the Poms were hahaha!!
Posted 13:21 28th November 2010
davodiablo says...
Nicholas41 says...
Gosh, there's some English bashing going on here isn't there? And some people's English is, well, not good to say the least. Some you SH types have taken the gift of rugby from England and do marvellously well at it. Jolly well done. Now, try to make a better job of the English itself, I say, what?
I assume your tongue is firmly in cheek ? If not that's just the sort of comment that makes pommy bashing so much fun . Innit bruv !
Posted 11:24 28th November 2010
Brett says...
@couchspud.. unfortunately the Boks do not have the luxury to pick the best players
Obviously PDVs prerequisite in obtaining his position was to bring in more "coloured players" this he has done consistently, working on a minimum of 5 players of colour in his squads, this juggling act in itself is a feat no wonder he hasnt come up with any new ideas regarding play !
As Ive stated before count yourselves lucky that your teams dont have this handicap to deal with! ps This is not a whine it is just the reality of SA Rugby
Posted 10:20 28th November 2010
Meneer says...
In all fairness the only team that delivers continually are the All Blacks, yes my beloved Boks won yesterday - but really against a rubbish England team who have no chance of contending for the 6 nations let alone the world cup.
Posted 10:06 28th November 2010
davodiablo says...
I don't know where the English get their confidence in between games ? Okay they beat Australia but I didn't see it as a thrashing . I saw England play a good game but it was two tries each and if Aus had slotted their kicks it would have been real close.The Samoa game was won but not with out a few scares .
Tom Croft is on video here saying "we should have beaten the ABs" . I woke up the flatmate I laughed so hard .
So it was really great to see the bokkes get this , I'm really looking forward to reading(welsh) Stephen Jones today . I expect he'll resort to bagging the Haka or maybe a paragraph about NZ stealing Islanders with absolutely no firm evidence . Ironically the English team seems to reaping the benefit of a few Kiwis and Saffas in their side . Note to Banahan , it takes more than a few tats on yer arm ......blah blah blah
Posted 10:02 28th November 2010
Nicholas41 says...
Gosh, there's some English bashing going on here isn't there? And some people's English is, well, not good to say the least. Some you SH types have taken the gift of rugby from England and do marvellously well at it. Jolly well done. Now, try to make a better job of the English itself, I say, what?
Oh, and keep counting those chickens...
Posted 09:39 28th November 2010
razorwall says...
Boks played much better against England and were more organised than they were against the Scots. However Stuart Dickinson has plenty to answer for, in terms of the Boks not going home with the grand-slam.
Although KIWIs look like the team to beat for 2011 WC, it will be interesting to see how the refs deal with the interpretation of the rules at the world cup and how consistent this will be. This could actually be the difference, as world cup games are generally a tighter affair with teams being more reserved, and playing less of an expansive game.
If the refs are as good as George Clancy at 2011 WC, my prediction is:
SA, England Final with SA most likely to take the 2011 WC crown.
Posted 09:29 28th November 2010
patrickcawood says...
I have read this phrase many times over the last few weeks
England smashed Australia
England beat Australia, 2 tries each, England got all their kicks over and Australia didnt.
Australia smashed France last night, fact
Well done to the Boks, the forwards were awesome, the backs, pretty clueless at times.
With a decent game plan and a few creative players back they could win another WC and make it 3 in 5
Posted 08:08 28th November 2010
KiwiLad says...
All in all a good weekend for 3N sides..
A fired up Bok pack can be fantastic to watch, as long as you are not a part of the opposition...
On top of that the shackledraggers and imported guests destroy France with some scintilating backplay..
Abs far to good for Wales with a 5 tries to 1 kicking..
What will all the Media north of the equator have to say about the lack of real tests these boys play now??
Not a thing as the arrogant gits are far to arrogant to admit that perhaps they were wrong
Posted 06:47 28th November 2010
ruggafan says...
@couchspud. No need to ask who you support. There is always some ass..... that has some stupid comment to make. If the Mighty AB's loose next year ,what excuse will it be this time? Oh i'm sure you will find someone to blame.
Posted 05:49 28th November 2010