Related links
Teams
Also see
- Min-by-min: The Udine clash as it happened
- The match in pictures
South Africa finally got their end-of-year tour off the mark as they stuttered along to a 32-10 win over a determined Italy outfit at the Stadio Friuli in Udine on Saturday.
The Springboks will take the win, but this victory will do nothing to their self-esteem or credentials on this somewhat unrewarding trip of Europe that has only dented their title as world champions.
A comedy of errors from the visitors - most of them in the scrum against the Azzurri - didn't help the South Africans' cause to stamp their authority on a game that was touted as a warm-up for next week's finale against Ireland.
In front of another passionate home crowd, the Italians were their own worst enemies as the goal-kickers - in a repeat of last week's defeat to New Zealand - missed a number of penalties that would have given the scoreline a bit more respectability.
However, be that as it may, Italy were still able to stay in the contest at half-time after trailing 12-7 but failed to keep the pressure on as the men in green and gold ran in a further two tries to seal the deal.
It was South Africa's first win in their fourth match on tour, but while the final scoreline was emphatic enough in the Springboks' favour it was not the rousing performance that might have been hoped for to erase the memory of the past two weeks.
The Springboks scored four tries, all of them to the backs, and it was a day where the South Africans should have been exceedingly thankful that they had a massive advantage behind the scrum.
For the umpteenth time on this tour, the Boks were pummelled in the set-scrums and if the truth be told, Italy's comfort in most aspects of the forward battle should be taken as a loud warning ahead of next week's big match in Dublin.
When playing the world champions as heavy underdogs the last thing you want to do is pay for some early indiscipline. But in his first start for Italy, flanker Simone Favaro charged upfield and hit scrum-half Fourie du Preez with a stupid late tackle that earned him a yellow card and resulted in a simple penalty in front of the posts.
Morne Steyn produced a most uncharacteristic mistake by missing, however the South Africans quickly struck with a great try which was fashioned by a break from Ryan Kankowski for Bryan Habana to capitalise on the quick ball that was spread out wide in the sixth minute.
Steyn missed the conversion but just after Favaro was allowed back on, Habana beat Matteo Pratichetti on the outside and slipped the ball inside for Jaque Fourie to score under the posts.
Steyn finally landed a kick and with 14 minutes gone the hosts were already 12-0 down. It looked as though it might be one-way traffic, but up to that point there had yet to be a set scrum. When the teams did finally scrum down, the Italians were as solid as a house, and completely destroyed the Boks with the second scrum of the match.
Italy continued to improve and should have scored as Alessandro Zanni broke to within a metre of the line but his support was slow in reaching him and the Springboks cleared their lines thanks to a trademark Heinrich Brussow steal.
Italy's first shot at goal had to be taken upstairs to decide whether the ball had in fact managed to squeeze in between the uprights. Gower was convinced, but the TMO was not and with 30 minutes up on the clock, South Africa held on to their 12-point lead.
But the former Australian-born rugby league international finally came good a few minutes later as he gave a subtle inside pass to centre Gonzalo Garcia with Alberto Sgarbi acting as a decoy.
Completely flummoxing the Springbok backline, Garcia ran in untouched for a splendid touchdown that was clearly scripted to aim at one of the Bok weaknesses. Steyn held his line, but Adi Jacobs didn't hold his, and the try was all too easy. At 12-7, and with the scrum flying backwards, the Boks were in big trouble.
There was still time, though, for both Italy full-back Luke McLean and Steyn to miss penalties before the break.
Six minutes into the second period Steyn landed a penalty before McLean missed his second of the afternoon after Italy's scrum caused the kind of problems that had the All Blacks struggling a week ago.
But on 53 minutes, the Springboks scored after more calamitous Italian defending as Danie Rossouw broke a tackle on the left-hand touchline. The Bok flanker slipped the ball inside to Habana who cut inside and popped the ball to Du Preez, who held off Zanni and Mirco Bergamasco to score.
Gower soon pulled back three points from a penalty after his own midfield break but Steyn replied on 64 minutes to make it 10-25.
As Italian legs started to tire, gaps appeared and Du Preez scythed through following a line-out and fed replacement Wyand Olivier to score by the posts - his first in 26 Tests - with another replacement in the form of Ruan Pienaar converting.
With Jacobs struggling so much with his defensive game, and Ireland's Brian O'Driscoll licking his lips about his rematch with the Bok team that beat the British and Irish Lions in mid-year, the smart money should be on Olivier wearing the number twelve jersey at Croke Park.
But the area that should come under most scrutiny in the build-up to the final game of the tour is undeniably the front row. And against the Italians, this may be a timely pointer to the Springbok management as they consider their options.
Man of the match: Bryan Habana and Jaque Fourie were prominent in the Bok backline along with Heinrich Brussow in the forwards, but our vote goes with number nine Fourie du Preez who once again showed his running ability, kicking ability and try-scoring ability.
Moment of the match: All the tries scored in this match were gems, but we think Du Preez's touchdown after the break was what the Boks needed to shut the Italians out.
Villain of the match: Assistant referee James Jones appears to not like the colour green and gold. He was the man in charge during the Wembley defeat, penalizing the Boks unjustly at the breakdown, and was at it again - albeit from the touchline - today. As Bryan Habana attempted to save a touch-finder, the Welshman ruled the winger to have put a foot in touch when Habana was in fact.... in the air! Oh, and the Italians scored a great try from the ensuing line-out.
The scorers:
For Italy:
Tries: Garcia
Pens: Gower
Cons: Gower
For South Africa:
Tries: Habana, Fourie, Du Preez, Olivier
Cons: Steyn 2, Pienaar
Pens: Steyn 2
Yellow card: Favaro (Italy, 4mins)
Italy: 15 Luke McLean, 14 Matteo Pratichetti, 13 Alberto Sgarbi, 12 Gonzalo Garcia, 11 Mirco Bergamasco, 10 Craig Gower, 9 Simon Picone; 8 Sergio Parisse (c), 7 Alessandro Zanni, 6 Simone Favaro, 5 Quintin Geldenhuys, 4 Carlo Antonio Del Fava, 3 Martin Castrogiovanni, 2 Fabio Ongaro, 1 Salvatore Perugini.
Replacements: 16 Leonardo Ghiraldini, 17 Ignacio Rouyet, 18 Antonio Pavanello, 19 Josh Sole, 20 Mauro Bergamasco, 21 Tito Tebaldi, 22 Gonzalo Canale.
South Africa: 15 Zane Kirchner, 14 JP Pietersen, 13 Jaque Fourie, 12 Adi Jacobs, 11 Bryan Habana, 10 Morné Steyn, 9 Fourie du Preez, 8 Ryan Kankowski, 7 Danie Rossouw, 6 Heinrich Brüssow, 5 Andries Bekker, 4 Bakkies Botha, 3 John Smit (c), 2 Adriaan Strauss, 1 Wian du Preez.
Replacements: 16 Tendai Mtawarira, 17 BJ Botha, 18 Victor Matfield, 19 Jean Deysel, 20 Francois Hougaard, 21 Ruan Pienaar, 22 Wynand Olivier.
Referee: Alain Rolland (Ireland)
Comments
ProudSaffar says...
PDV needs to make few changes for Saturday. Adrian Jacobs needs to make place for Wynand Oliver and John Smit needs to go back to hooker and BJ should start at tighthead.
Then bring on Victor for Bekker and Schalk at 7 with Rossouw at 8. This is our strongest Team at the moment and will sort out our scrum worries.
We should play all out attack rugby. The Boks looked dangerous everytime they took the ball wide against Italy.
Posted 09:19 23rd November 2009
dougM says...
Boks weren't great but not nearly as bad as this article makes out! Certainly some worthwhile moments, highlighted by the other readers already, which are missing from this article. Most notably the fact that the SA scrum looked great once Smit moved to hooker. If we stick to the front row which finished the test I think we would have overcome a big weakness, then we have only 1 REALLY big weakness left, being Adi Jacobs in midfield. He is a good player but not international standard and must surely be replaced especially against the likes of BOD.
Posted 07:07 23rd November 2009
beninuk says...
Yes, when Smit played at hooker the Italian scrum went backwards several times.
Posted 15:34 22nd November 2009
Solitude says...
James Jones made me laugh. He really does have it out for South Africa. Alain Rolland must be commended though since he had a great game. There was no guessing what the referee would do since he did everything as he should have.
Great work mr Rolland!
Posted 09:43 22nd November 2009
rugbyphile says...
Planet Rugby journalism --Roussow's pass to Fourie was the best pass in all forms of rugby in a month and your report indicates it didn't happen--
Did I see the Italian scrum shunted backwards once BJ Botha came on and Smit went to hooker? And Castro.-- even though fresh from being clearly illegally rested-- copped a spray---that didn't happen either---
Great try from Garcia--Wallabies should take note how to break a line--plan ahead rather than just rely on Gits to improvise
Posted 05:52 22nd November 2009
EdwinO says...
Smit back at hooker! Maybe Div will come to his senses now.
Posted 04:08 22nd November 2009
bokbefok2009 says...
well spotted mate. hope they can pull themselves together for ireland
Posted 02:55 22nd November 2009
brianjar says...
Actually, one part of this report is incorrect. Russouw didn't pass inside to Habana. He reverse-passed outside (amazingly) to Fourie who passed to Habana and then to Du Preez for the try. It was a very highly skilled move.
Posted 23:07 21st November 2009
forzazzurri says...
I loved italy in the first half and I still loved 'em in second half but ...............
anyhow hail to the world champions and please please lets beat samoa next saturday to gain some sort of self-esteem.
PS
why did we have to miss so many easy kicks ?
Posted 19:22 21st November 2009
jacquessa says...
well done bokke. get better and we will stand after you all. no matter how good or bad you are....
Posted 17:32 21st November 2009